Mistakes Customer Service Reps Make That Lose Sales
Your Customer Service Representatives are your company’s front line and play a critical role in your brand’s overall success. They are the gatekeepers to great sales.
But here’s the problem:
Customer Service Reps aren’t salespeople.
They don’t have the acute skills of a salesperson to hear new opportunities for sales on calls. And while they might be excellent at keeping your customers happy, they might also be costing you sales because they don’t know the signs of a hot prospect.
There are 2 key areas where they might be making mistakes that are costing you sales.
Giving Away Price Without Proving Value
Price is an important question in the sales process. It’s often the first question prospects ask. But it shouldn’t be the first question your service team answers!
The problem with giving away price at the jump is that it makes it easy for people to give you a quick “no”. Priced-based shoppers want what’s the cheapest. To win more sales, service reps should open the conversation with value.
To prove this point, let's examine a quick story about how a client we work with got around the price question and won a customer based on value.

The higher the perceived benefit, the higher the customer value, and the greater likelihood that customers will choose that product.
It started with price but ended with value
“Company X” is honest that they aren't the cheapest provider in their service area. But, they do provide excellent service that helps customers see past the price.
They suffered from the problem of sales calls starting and stopping with the “price” question.
An opportunity to help train the service reps came when a man walked into the office and said, “I drive past you all the time. What are your prices for [this service]?”
Fortunately, the VP was at the front desk and chimed in. He immediately asked questions about this person’s needs, requirements, and their current service provider.
By shifting the conversation from price to the person’s problem, Company X was able to prove their expertise and value to the gentleman at the front desk.
He signed up on the spot!
Moral of the story: communicating value can beat price objections
Giving out product pricing without proving value opens the door to objections and ultimate rejection of your business. Instead, your service reps should have a strategy for follow-up questions that introduce your business as a valuable partner in keeping their home or business running.
Not Following Up with Interested Leads
The sales cycle for most products and services is quick. Most people wait until they cannot put up with a given issue any longer and they want their problems taken care of quickly.
But, that does not mean that every interested party will sign up in 1 phone call.
Many will want to go back over their budget and give your company a ring back when they’re ready to move forward.
So, what happens when the prospect forgets to call you back?
What happens all too often is they move on to another company. And then your lead and your sales pipeline are stuck in limbo.
Quick follow-up is key in closing leads in short sales cycles.
Unfortunately, many service reps don’t follow up with leads after the initial phone call. This mistake means that even highly interested prospects will fall out of your sales pipeline.
Close More Sales By Giving Service Reps the Support They Need
These mistakes don’t mean your customer service team isn’t doing their job. It means they need more support from you—and perhaps some professionals.
Improve sales close rates with scripts and training
Your service reps aren’t salespeople. They might be uncomfortable being “pushy” on the phone. Or, they might feel their other responsibilities mean turning a question into a conversation is time they don’t have.
This is okay as long as they’re willing to try some new tactics.
- Scripts for Phone Calls can give your service reps language that makes it easy for them to guide the conversation.
- Sales Training, even at the beginner level, can give them tools on how to make each phone call a better opportunity
Make sure you have a strategy in place for the handoff of leads to ensure potential sales don’t fall through the cracks.
Internal change can be difficult. Seek a coach’s help.
Especially during busy times at the company, asking your service reps to do things differently can be a challenge.
Enlisting help from a sales coach can help smooth the process. A sales coach will help hold your customer service team accountable. An outside voice might help your team take the changes more seriously and make you more successful in its implementation.
Consider hiring a salesperson
Your expertise no doubt adds confidence to the sales process, but it also pulls your attention away from focusing on the strategy for growing your fuel delivery company or making it more efficient.
Hiring a salesperson to work with your service reps on new leads can improve your sales close rate. Their dedicated position means that they can follow up faster with prospects to keep leads moving through the buyer’s journey until they become a customer.
Increase Sales By Utilizing Your Customer Sales Reps to their Fullest Potential
Your sales reps provide excellent customer service. Help them make your sales cycle just as excellent by winning more sales.
Changing your sales rate starts with the first phone call a customer makes.
Listen in on a few calls with your sales reps and see if they too struggle with communicating value and following up with leads. If they do, consider taking some of the steps above to improve your process.
